Call 24/7 for a Free Case Review

(888) 233-5020

(619) 233-5020

No Fee Guarantee®

CA Supreme Court Appears Poised to Side with Insurance Companies

By Ross Jurewitz on May 29, 2011

We have previously written about the very important California Court of Appeals decision handed down in the case of Howell v. Hamilton Meats and Provisions‚ Inc. which clarified that the collateral source rule is still the law in California‚ thereby permitting injured people to recover the full amounts of their medical bills from the negligent party rather than just the amount “paid” by their insurance company via monetary payment.  You can read a prior article and the Court of Appeals opinion here.

Now‚ after the California Supreme Court heard oral arguments during the appeal‚ it appears that the highest court in the state is poised to side with insurance companies and drastically limit or change the collateral source rule–for the benefit of negligent parties and their insurance companies.  That is the exact OPPOSITE rationale for why the collateral source rule exists:  the tortfeasor should not benefit for the foresight of the injured person in purchasing and then paying for health insurance prior to the accident‚ sometimes for years. did a writeup of the oral arguments and it appears that the justices of the Court were very cold to the idea of maintaining the law and the collateral source rule as is.  Nobody is sure what changes are coming‚ but it appears certain that change will be coming–and at the expense of injured Californians for the benefit of insurance companies.

Ross Jurewitz

Ross Jurewitz is the founder and managing lawyer of the Jurewitz Law Group, a San Diego personal injury attorney law firm. These San Diego injury accident lawyers specialize in helping people seriously injured in a variety of accidents throughout San Diego County and California.

Connect with Ross Jurewitz on

Related Articles:

Call the Jurewitz Law Group at (619) 233-5020 and begin your path to recovery with a no-cost consultation today.

Downtown San Diego Location

600 B Street, Suite 1550
San Diego, California 92101
Phone: (619) 233-5020
Fax: (888) 233-3180
Toll Free: (888) 233-5020
Click to see Map

North County San Diego Location

2244 Faraday Ave. Suite 101
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Phone: (760) 585-4640
Fax: (888) 233-3180
Toll Free: (888) 233-5020
Click to see Map

Copyright © 2018 Jurewitz Law Group, All Rights Reserved, Reproduced with Permission. Serving communities throughout Southern California.

San Diego Personal Injury Attorney Disclaimer: The legal information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice, nor the formation of a lawyer or attorney client relationship. Any results set forth herein are based upon the facts of that particular case and do not represent a promise or guarantee. Please contact a lawyer for a consultation on your particular legal matter. This web site is not intended to solicit clients for matters outside of the state of California.

Website Design, SEO and Legal Internet Marketing by: SLS Consulting